Here in Southeastern Pennsylvania, we know that storms can knock out the power without warning. That’s why a standby generator is such a smart investment for homeowners in Chester, Montgomery, and surrounding counties. Once you decide to get one, the next step is figuring out the fuel. Your property’s access to a utility line is the biggest factor in the propane vs natural gas generator discussion. If you have a natural gas hookup, it’s an incredibly convenient option. If not, propane offers a powerful and highly dependable alternative. Let’s look at the practical realities of each so you can choose the right system for your Pennsylvania home.

Contact Us

Key Takeaways

  • Check Your Fuel Access First: Your decision starts with what’s available. A natural gas line at your home offers a convenient, cost-effective option, while propane provides a powerful and reliable alternative with its own on-site storage.
  • Balance Convenience with Control: Natural gas provides a hands-off, continuous fuel supply but depends on the utility grid. Propane gives you an independent power source that you control, but it requires you to manage your fuel supply through refills.
  • Get an Expert Opinion for the Right Fit: Don’t guess on your power needs. A professional assessment is the best way to ensure your generator is sized correctly for your home and installed safely, guaranteeing it will work flawlessly when you need it.

Propane vs. Natural Gas: What’s the Difference?

When you’re choosing a standby generator, one of the biggest decisions is the fuel source. Propane and natural gas are the two most common and reliable options, but they aren’t interchangeable. Understanding how they differ in terms of fuel delivery, power output, and installation is the first step to finding the perfect fit for your home and peace of mind.

The right choice often comes down to what’s available at your property and what your specific power needs are during an outage. Both are excellent fuels that can keep your lights on and your family comfortable, but they get the job done in slightly different ways. Let’s break down the key distinctions so you can feel confident in your decision.

How They’re Fueled

The most fundamental difference between these two fuels is how they get to your generator. Natural gas is a fossil fuel delivered directly to your home through underground utility lines, just like your water or electricity. This means you have a continuous, uninterrupted supply straight from the source. As long as the utility lines are intact, your generator will have fuel.

Propane, on the other hand, is stored on your property in a dedicated tank. It’s a byproduct of natural gas processing and is compressed into a liquid for easy storage. This makes it a fantastic option if you don’t have access to a natural gas line. The trade-off is that you are responsible for monitoring the fuel level and scheduling refills with a propane supplier.

Power and Efficiency

When it comes to energy, not all fuels are created equal. Propane is more energy-dense than natural gas. In simple terms, a cubic foot of propane contains more than double the energy (about 2,500 BTUs) of a cubic foot of natural gas (about 1,000 BTUs). This means a Generac generator running on propane can often produce more power than the same model running on natural gas.

While that might sound like a clear win for propane, both fuels are incredibly efficient and more than capable of powering your home. The choice isn’t about which one is “better” but which one best aligns with the power requirements of your home and the generator model you select.

Design and Installation

Your fuel choice directly impacts the installation process. A natural gas generator is permanently connected to your home’s existing gas line, making it a seamless part of your utility setup. If you already have natural gas service for your furnace or stove, the installation is typically straightforward for a certified professional.

A propane generator installation involves placing a storage tank on your property. This gives you more flexibility, as you aren’t tied to a utility grid, making it the go-to solution for rural homes or properties without gas service. A professional team will help you determine the right size and location for the tank to ensure your residential standby generator installation is safe and compliant with local codes.

The Pros and Cons of Propane Generators

Choosing a fuel source is one of the biggest decisions you’ll make when installing a home generator. Propane is an incredibly popular and reliable option, especially for homeowners who don’t have access to a natural gas line. Like any choice, it comes with its own set of benefits and considerations. Understanding these points will help you decide if a propane-fueled generator is the right fit for keeping your home powered during an outage.

Why Choose a Propane Generator?

One of the biggest advantages of propane is its stability. Unlike gasoline, which can degrade in just a few months, propane can be stored for years without going bad. This means your fuel is always ready when you need it most. Propane also burns very cleanly, which is not only better for the environment but also easier on your generator’s engine. A cleaner burn often translates to less wear and tear and simpler generator maintenance over the long run. On top of that, propane is more energy-dense than natural gas, meaning it packs more power into every gallon, giving you an efficient and robust source of backup energy.

Potential Downsides of Propane

While propane is a fantastic fuel, there are a few practical points to consider. The main one is storage. Because propane isn’t piped to your home, you’ll need a dedicated tank on your property that a supplier must refill periodically. This requires space and adds the task of monitoring your fuel levels. In very cold weather, propane can sometimes have a harder time vaporizing, which might affect startup, though modern Generac generators are built to perform reliably in a wide range of climates. The cost of propane can also fluctuate with the market, so it’s a good idea to think about the logistics and ongoing expense of fuel delivery.

The Pros and Cons of Natural Gas Generators

If your home is already connected to a natural gas line, this type of generator can be an incredibly convenient choice. It taps directly into your existing utility, offering a steady fuel source without the need for storage tanks. This “set it and forget it” approach is a major plus for many homeowners who want reliable backup power with minimal fuss.

However, that reliance on the grid can also be a drawback. Let’s walk through the specific advantages and potential disadvantages of choosing a natural gas generator for your home.

Why Choose a Natural Gas Generator?

The biggest advantage of a natural gas generator is the continuous fuel supply. Because it connects directly to your utility line, you never have to worry about refueling or running out of power during an extended outage. Natural gas also tends to be more affordable than propane, which can lead to lower running costs over time.

It’s also a cleaner-burning fuel compared to diesel or gasoline, making it a more environmentally friendly option. From a safety perspective, natural gas is lighter than air, so if a leak were to occur, it would dissipate quickly into the atmosphere. A professional residential standby generator installation ensures your connection is secure, giving you peace of mind.

Potential Downsides of Natural Gas

The main drawback of a natural gas generator is its complete dependence on the utility grid. In the rare event of a natural disaster that disrupts the gas supply lines, your generator won’t be able to run. This makes it less ideal for off-grid living or for those who want total independence from public utilities.

Natural gas also has a slightly lower energy output than propane. This means that for the same amount of fuel, you get a little less power. While modern Generac generators are highly efficient, this is still a factor to consider when sizing a unit for your home’s needs. Finally, since they require a pipeline connection, these generators are stationary and cannot be used for portable power.

Comparing the Costs: Propane vs. Natural Gas

When you’re deciding on a major home investment like a generator, the budget is always a big part of the conversation. But the total cost of a generator isn’t just the number on the price tag. You have to consider the upfront installation expenses and the long-term cost of fuel over the life of the machine. Both propane and natural gas generators have their own cost structures, and understanding them will help you make a choice that feels right for your home and your wallet. Let’s break down what you can expect, from the day of installation to the years of reliable power that follow.

Upfront Installation Costs

The initial investment for a generator involves more than just the unit itself; it’s the total cost of getting it set up and running. The final price for a residential standby generator installation depends heavily on your property’s existing infrastructure. If your home is already connected to a natural gas line, the hookup process can be fairly straightforward. However, if a line needs to be extended to your property, that can add to the expense. For propane generators, you’ll need a dedicated storage tank installed, and the cost will vary based on its size and whether you choose an above-ground or buried option. Every home is unique, so a professional site assessment is the best way to get a clear picture of the total upfront cost.

Long-Term Running Costs

Once your generator is installed, its primary ongoing expense is fuel. This is where natural gas often has a distinct advantage. As a utility-supplied fuel, natural gas is generally more affordable than propane—sometimes costing as little as 40% of the price of propane for the same amount of power. Over the 20- to 30-year lifespan of your generator, these fuel savings can add up substantially, especially if you live in an area with frequent or prolonged power outages. While the initial investment is a key factor, considering the long-term running costs is just as crucial for your financial planning. To help manage this important home upgrade, we offer several Generac financing options.

How Local Availability Affects Price

Ultimately, the most practical and cost-effective choice often comes down to what’s available at your home. If you already have a natural gas line, it’s typically the most convenient and economical option. However, for many homes in our service areas, particularly in more rural parts of Chester, Montgomery, Bucks, and Delaware Counties, natural gas infrastructure may not be accessible. In these cases, propane is a fantastic and highly reliable alternative. The right decision really depends on your specific location and setup. Having a professional evaluate your property is the best way to understand which fuel source makes the most sense for you.

Generator Maintenance: What to Expect

Once your generator is installed, you want peace of mind, not another long list of chores. The good news is that both propane and natural gas generators are designed for reliability with minimal fuss. However, their maintenance needs do differ slightly, and understanding these differences can help you choose the best fit for your lifestyle.

Regular, professional check-ups are the key to ensuring your generator is ready the moment you need it. Just like your car, your generator has a motor and moving parts that benefit from routine care. A planned Generac maintenance schedule catches small issues before they become big problems, ensuring your investment protects your home for years to come. Whether you choose propane or natural gas, a little preventative care goes a long way in keeping the lights on.

Maintaining a Propane Generator

If you’re looking for a low-maintenance option, a propane generator is an excellent choice. Propane is an incredibly stable fuel source. Unlike gasoline, it doesn’t degrade over time, which means you don’t have to worry about stale fuel clogging up the system. A propane tank can be stored for years and the fuel inside will be ready to go.

This stability simplifies upkeep. You don’t need to clean the carburetor or drain the tank and lines if the generator sits unused for a long time. This “set it and forget it” quality is perfect for homeowners who want a reliable backup power source without the hands-on work.

Maintaining a Natural Gas Generator

Natural gas generators are the definition of convenience when it comes to fuel management. Since they connect directly to your home’s natural gas line, they have a constant, uninterrupted fuel supply. This means you never have to worry about refueling or scheduling fuel deliveries. The generator simply draws what it needs, when it needs it.

This direct connection eliminates the need for fuel storage and management, which simplifies the overall maintenance routine. The only thing to keep in mind is that in a widespread natural disaster that disrupts utility lines, the gas supply could be affected. While this is rare, it’s a factor to consider when weighing your options for Generac generators.

Common Myths About Generator Upkeep

Let’s clear up a few common misconceptions about generator care. One myth is that you have to run your generator frequently to keep it in good shape. While all generators benefit from a weekly self-test cycle, propane’s fuel stability means it can remain ready for long periods without extra work from you.

Another misconception is that propane isn’t as reliable as other fuel types. With proper care and professional generator service and repair, propane generators are incredibly dependable. The truth is, reliability isn’t about the fuel type—it’s about the quality of the machine and the consistency of its maintenance.

How to Choose the Right Generator for Your Home

Picking the right generator feels like a big decision, because it is. You’re investing in peace of mind for your family and security for your home. The best choice between a propane and a natural gas generator isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer; it really comes down to your specific situation. To figure out what’s right for you, you’ll want to look at three key things: how much power you actually need, what fuel sources are available at your property, and why getting an expert opinion can save you headaches down the road. Thinking through these points will help you land on a solution that keeps your lights on and your life running smoothly, no matter the weather.

Assess Your Power Needs

First, let’s figure out what you need to power during an outage. Make a list of your essentials. Are you looking to keep just the basics running, like the refrigerator, a few lights, and your well pump? Or do you need to power your entire home, including the air conditioning, home office equipment, and medical devices? The size of your home and the number of appliances you want to run will determine the size of the generator you need. If your residential standby generator installation requires a larger, more powerful unit, propane can often provide more energy to meet those higher demands.

Evaluate Your Fuel Availability

Your property’s location and existing utilities play a huge role in this decision. Natural gas is a convenient option if you already have a line running to your house. It provides a continuous fuel supply, so you never have to worry about refills. However, natural gas service isn’t available everywhere, and extending a line can be costly. If you don’t have access to natural gas, a propane generator is an excellent alternative. Propane is stored in a tank on your property, giving you an independent fuel source that’s reliable even if municipal services are interrupted. We can help you explore the Generac generators that work best with your available fuel source.

Why Professional Guidance Matters

You don’t have to make this decision alone. Getting professional guidance is the best way to ensure you choose a generator that’s perfectly sized for your needs and installed correctly and safely. An expert can perform a detailed assessment of your home’s electrical system and power requirements. A Generac generator is one of the best investments you can make for your home, and a proper installation ensures it will be ready to kick in within seconds of an outage. The right advice from our team gives you confidence that your generator will perform reliably when you need it most.

Related Articles

Contact Us

Frequently Asked Questions

Is one fuel type definitively better than the other? Not at all. The “better” choice really depends on your home’s location and your specific needs. If you already have a natural gas line, its convenience and lower long-term fuel costs are very appealing. But if you don’t have access to natural gas, or if you value having a fuel source that’s completely independent of the utility grid, then propane is an incredibly powerful and reliable solution.

What if I don’t have a natural gas line at my home? That’s a common situation, and it’s precisely why propane generators are such a fantastic option. Propane provides a completely self-contained power solution for your home. The system includes a dedicated storage tank on your property, giving you a dependable fuel source that doesn’t rely on municipal gas lines, making it perfect for any property without existing gas service.

How do I know what size generator my home needs? The best way to figure this out is to consider what you absolutely need running during an outage. Do you just want to cover essentials like the refrigerator, some lights, and your well pump? Or do you prefer to power the entire house, including the air conditioning and home office? A professional assessment is the surest way to calculate your specific power load and match you with a generator that can handle it without issue.

How often will I need to refill a propane tank? This depends on the size of your tank and how frequently you experience power outages. For most homeowners, a properly sized tank can last through multiple outages. Many systems can also be fitted with a monitor that automatically alerts you or your supplier when fuel is low, so you can schedule a refill long before it becomes a concern.

How quickly does a standby generator actually turn on during an outage? It’s impressively fast. A modern standby generator is designed to sense a power loss immediately. Within just a few seconds of the utility power cutting out, the generator automatically starts up and the transfer switch safely connects it to your home. You’ll likely only notice a brief moment of quiet before your lights and appliances are back up and running.